Cake Plates

I have a thing for dishes. 

A serious...thing. 

What I need is to either get rid of some or get more storage. 

Instead...I'm going to talk about my interest in these dishes. 

photos: Rosanna Inc. 

AND THESE.....

via: Kate Spade

Considering these plates both come in sets of 4, are the same price and also have an optional cake stand, which interpretation do you like better?